Your audience will judge your entire event by what happens on the main stage, and your leadership will judge you. That makes choosing a keynote speaker one of the highest stakes decisions a meeting planner makes.
After more than 30 years as a professional speaker, I have seen the selection process from every side. The planners who consistently get it right follow a disciplined process. They understand how recommendations are made, they insist on customization, they test pedigree and fit with evidence, and they prepare their speaker as carefully as they prepare their venue. Here are the five steps.
What the right speaker brings to your event
Real pedigree
Expertise earned by doing the work, not by researching it, and respected by your audience.
The right fit
A delivery style and message aligned with your theme, your sector, and the moment your audience is in.
Disciplined preparation
A customized plan, a keynote wireframe, and the files and resources that protect show day.
The five steps below are how your selection committee secures all three.
Search, and follow the money
Whether you are working with a speaker bureau or going directly to a speaker’s website, always begin by following the money. It is not uncommon for participants in the speaking industry to have a financial interest in who they recommend. Speaker bureaus typically maintain a list of exclusive speakers, and recommending one of them can carry a financial advantage for the bureau.
I have partnered with speaker bureaus for years, and the overwhelming majority are excellent. They add real value, and you should not hesitate to work with one. Simply ask whether each recommended speaker is exclusive or non-exclusive, so you can decide whether it matters to your selection.
Keep one more point in mind. True professional speakers have one price, essentially their retail fee, and a bureau’s commission typically comes out of that fee. You are not likely to save money by going direct. And remember that the most popular speakers are not always the best. Many are simply skilled at digital marketing. Ask colleagues who they have booked and who they would book again.
Ask the bureau
Which of these speakers are exclusive to you, and which are non-exclusive?
Has anyone on your team seen this speaker present live in the last year?
Warning sign
You are choosing a speaker mainly because their name appears everywhere online. Visibility measures marketing skill, not expertise.
Set the ground rules and hold a video discovery call
Lay down the ground rules early. Every candidate should know that you expect a customized presentation that is highly relevant to your industry and your audience, and that they must be willing to work with you through a customization process.
Start with a discovery session to confirm fit. A great speaker will never accept an opportunity they do not believe they can absolutely nail for their meeting planner client. Hold that meeting by video conference. It gives your selection team the chance to ask tough questions, confirm real experience with your topic and sector, get a genuine sense of the speaker’s personality, and preview their stage presence.
Never hire a speaker until you have held a video discovery call with them, under any circumstances.
Vet and select with evidence
In your selection process, make sure you do three things. First, confirm a real pedigree that is closely targeted to your audience. I speak on future trends and innovation, and what makes me credible is not that I talk about innovation. I have been awarded more than 40 patents, written bestselling books on the subject, and I provide innovation consulting to leading brands. Your audience needs real world expertise that goes beyond an internet search.
Second, align delivery style with your event. If leaders are gathering to navigate major organizational change, a comedy act would be wrong, and so would a somber lecture. You need a speaker who can address change with a sober but optimistic approach. Third, be practical about credibility. Your audience decides whether a speaker is believable on a topic, and when your event is on the line, that matters.
Beware what I call the TED talk syndrome: a dramatic proclamation, a long pause, and a platitude that makes thin content sound profound. A TED appearance is not, by itself, a credential. Then interview hard and talk to the meeting planners from the speaker’s last two or three events. Do not let a speaker cherry pick references.
| Criterion | What to look for | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Pedigree | Expertise earned by doing the work, respected by your audience | 25% |
| Audience and sector fit | Deep understanding of your industry and the people in the room | 20% |
| Delivery style | A tone that matches the theme and the moment of your event | 15% |
| Customization | A clear, willing process to tailor the presentation | 15% |
| References | Strong feedback from the last two or three events | 15% |
| Readiness and value | Clear AV requirements and value added resources | 10% |
Ask the speaker
What have you personally built, led, or achieved in this topic, outside of speaking about it?
May we speak with the planners from your last two or three events?
Warning sign
The credentials lean on where the speaker has spoken rather than what they have actually done.
Prepare with a keynote wireframe
Once you decide to move forward, your speaker should book a detailed pre-event meeting of about one hour with your team to fully understand your goals and objectives, your sector, and the forces affecting your audience.
At the end of that meeting, ask for a keynote wireframe: a detailed overview of the opening act, the main act, and the closing act, with the stories, delivery style, and content planned for each. Never accept a slide deck in place of a wireframe. A strong deck is little more than 30 to 60 images with almost no text. It is a backdrop, not the presentation, so it cannot show you what the speaker has in mind.
Approve the wireframe, or ask for course corrections by email or in another meeting. A great speaker will gladly spend another hour fine tuning a message that is this important to your event.
Ask the speaker
When will we receive your keynote wireframe?
How will you connect your session to the sessions before and after it?
Warning sign
You receive a slide deck when you asked for a wireframe.
Collect the deliverables and value added resources
After the wireframe is approved, your speaker should provide the full presentation file after a quality check of every font and transition, with any videos embedded and also supplied as separate files. They should also provide a detailed AV requirements document, like the one on our How to Book Nicholas Webb page, including a PDF with thumbnails of every slide so your AV team can confirm nothing was damaged moving between computers.
Finally, ask for value added resources. A comprehensive, customized white paper gives attendees more detail without forcing them to take notes, and digital copies of a recent book extend the session’s impact. Great keynote speakers love to provide more value than expected, so you should not expect any pushback.
Ask the speaker
Will you provide a quality checked presentation file, a slide PDF, and an AV requirements document?
What value added resources can you provide for our attendees?
Warning sign
Files and AV requirements are still missing two weeks before your event.
Make the decision with confidence
When your committee follows these five steps, the choice stops being a guess. You know how each recommendation was made, you have seen every candidate on camera, you have scored them on the same criteria, and you have approved a plan for every act of the keynote.
The free Meeting Planner Innovation Superstar® Guide to Speaker Selection puts the full process in your hands, with hard hitting interview questions, scoring sheets, a weighted scorecard to compare finalists, and trackers for every deliverable.
Your audience will judge your speaker by what they have done, not by what they say. Choose accordingly.
Questions planners ask
Is it cheaper to book a speaker directly instead of through a bureau?
Usually not. True professional speakers have one price, and a bureau’s commission typically comes out of the speaker’s fee. Choose the channel that serves you best.
How early should we start the speaker search?
For a major conference, begin nine to twelve months out, so you have time for discovery calls, reference checks, and a pre-event meeting.
What is a keynote wireframe?
A detailed plan for the opening act, main act, and closing act, including the stories, content, and delivery style. It lets you approve the message before the presentation is built.
Which references should we ask for?
The meeting planners from the speaker’s last two or three events, in order, rather than a list of favorites.
